Total Tax Burden: Why "No Income Tax" States Aren't Always Cheapest
Income tax is one of three or four state taxes. When you look only at income tax, the cheapest state analysis is wrong. Property tax, sales tax, estate tax, and business taxes complete the picture. This page shows where each no-income-tax state actually stands when you count everything.
Last reviewed April 2026. Sources: Tax Foundation State-Local Tax Burden Rankings 2024, BEA, state revenue departments.
The Three Tax Categories That Matter
Income Tax
Range: 0% to 13.3% (CA)
The most visible tax. Powerful lever for high earners. Does not affect anyone paying $0 income tax already.
No-tax state offenders: NH: 3% on interest/div above $2,400; WA: 7% cap gains above $250K
Property Tax
Range: 0.27% (HI) to 2.23% (NJ)
Often ignored in income-tax comparisons. For a $500K homeowner, each 1% of rate = $5,000/yr.
No-tax state offenders: NH: 1.86% (4th highest nationally), TX: 1.60% (6th highest), SD: 1.08%
Sales Tax
Range: 0% to 9.55% combined (TN)
Hits consumers directly. Regressive (hits lower incomes harder). Varies enormously.
No-tax state offenders: TN: 9.55% highest in US, WA: 9.20%, TX: 8.19%, NV: 8.23%
The 9 No Income Tax States: Ranked by Total Burden
| Rank | State | Income Tax | Property Tax | Sales Tax | Total Burden |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Wyoming (WY) Mineral severance taxes fund the state | 0% | 0.56% | 5.36% | Low |
| 2 | South Dakota (SD) No corporate income tax; trust law haven | 0% | 1.08% | 6.10% | Low |
| 3 | Alaska (AK) PFD pays residents; high cost of living | 0% | 1.04% | 0.00% | Low |
| 4 | Florida (FL) Tourism taxes subsidize resident burden | 0% | 0.86% | 7.02% | Below avg |
| 5 | Nevada (NV) Gaming taxes = tourist subsidy for residents | 0% | 0.53% | 8.23% | Below avg |
| 6 | Tennessee (TN) Highest sales tax in the nation | 0% | 0.64% | 9.55% | Near avg |
| 7 | New Hampshire (NH) 4th highest property tax nationally | 0% | 1.86% | 0.00% | Above avg |
| 8 | Texas (TX) 6th highest property tax; franchise tax | 0% | 1.60% | 8.19% | Near avg |
| 9 | Washington (WA) 7% cap gains tax + B&O + estate tax | 0% | 0.94% | 9.20% | Above avg |
Case Studies: The Hidden Taxes
The Texas Trap
Texas has no income tax and the narrative is powerful: 'The second-largest US economy, no income tax, business-friendly, good weather.' But on a $400,000 home, property tax is approximately $6,400 per year at the 1.60% average rate. A Californian earning $120,000 who moves to Texas saves approximately $8,400 in income tax annually but pays approximately $3,500 more in property tax on the same home value. The net saving is real ($4,900/yr) but much smaller than the headline suggests. For a Californian earning $75,000, the income tax saving is about $3,000 and the property tax increase is about the same. Net saving: near zero.
The Tennessee Grocery Bill
Tennessee's 9.55% combined sales tax rate is the highest in the nation. A family of four with $45,000 in annual taxable spending (excluding housing costs) pays $4,298 in sales tax. Crucially, Tennessee taxes groceries at a 4% reduced state rate plus applicable local taxes (totaling 5-6% in most counties). A household spending $12,000 per year on groceries pays approximately $600-720 extra per year on food alone versus a state that exempts groceries (like Texas, Florida, or Wyoming).
The New Hampshire Lie
New Hampshire is marketed as a no-income-tax, no-sales-tax paradise in the Northeast. This is literally true and superficially attractive. But New Hampshire's average effective property tax rate of 1.86% is the 4th highest in the nation. On the state's median home price of $465,000, annual property tax is $8,649. Compare to Massachusetts: a resident earning $120,000 saves $6,000 in income tax by moving to New Hampshire but gains $4,000 in extra property tax on the same home. The net advantage is real but modest, and it reverses completely for lower-income homeowners with expensive homes.
The Alaska PFD Bonus
Alaska is genuinely unusual: no state income tax, no state sales tax, and the state pays you. The Permanent Fund Dividend pays eligible Alaska residents $1,000 to $3,000 per year depending on oil fund performance. A family of four received $13,136 from the PFD in 2022 (the exceptional year). In a normal year it is $4,000 to $7,000 per family. This is a genuine financial benefit that no other state offers. The catch: Alaska's cost of living is 27.5% above the national average, which costs a typical family approximately $12,000 to $18,000 more per year versus a state at the national average.
Other Taxes You May Not Have Counted
7% on long-term gains above $250K/yr. Upheld by state Supreme Court March 2023. Potentially $35,000+ per year for active investors.
10-20% on estates above $2.193M. One of only 6 states with a state estate tax. Major issue for high-net-worth retirees.
0.75% of taxable margin for businesses above $2.47M revenue. Sole proprietors exempt. Can add thousands per year for businesses.
Business franchise tax (0.25% of net worth) plus excise tax (6.5% of net income). Applies to many business structures including LLCs.
0.47-0.48% gross receipts tax on all business revenue. No deduction for expenses. Unique in the US and burdensome for low-margin businesses.
0.7% on real estate transactions. On a $400K home purchase: $2,800 in one-time transfer taxes.
FAQ
Which state has the lowest total tax burden?
Which no income tax state has the highest total burden?
What taxes do no income tax states use instead?
How does the Tax Foundation measure total tax burden?
Sources: Tax Foundation State-Local Tax Burden Rankings 2024 (taxfoundation.org), BEA Regional Price Parity, state revenue department websites. Last reviewed April 2026. Not tax advice.